This is a very well made video that shows a common situation faced, not only by engineers but, by almost everybody that has a logical and analytical mind when confronted by people that think they know your job better than you do. Enjoy :)
This is an old post that I deleted by accident when I transferred my blog from zuco.org to blog.zuco.co Many people asked me about this post, it seems that many of them linked it in their sites getting a broken link. Sorry for that! I decided to put it back and update it a little bit. Also the redirection is fixed so old links will point to the right place. Here we go:
Some years ago I was talking with my friend David about stupidity. He told me about the definition of stupidity by Carlo Maria Cipolla, an italian history and economy professor. Cipolla deeply studied the concept about human stupidity trying to define it and creating the 5 laws of stupidity. There are many studies related to this but until now none of them could provide a clear definition of it. Stupidity appears in a subjective and human environment but detailed definitions are hard to achieve.
Anyway, the explanation of Cipolla could be resumed in a diagram representing, that in one word is a way to understand human life.
1. I benefit myself damaging others
Unfortunately this is the common posture in this planet. Everything is based on self profit and nobody cares about the impact of his/her own behavior unto others. Just look around on this planet and realize that the vast majority try to achieve this point. Banks, big corporations and governments, don’t care about the pain in this world, exploiting any resource for their own interests.
2. I benefit others and damage myself
This is the position of the altruist. The good guy, the one that doesn’t care to damage him/herself to help others. Unfortunately people like this is rare and the few ones that exist usually become an object of cult.
3. I damage others and I damage myself
This is the behavior of the stupid. His/her behavior does not create any benefit for anybody. Unfortunately this is the the common result in this world. Almost anybody try to behave as in point 1 but at the end almost everybody ends in this point, doing the most stupid thing: Hurting him/herself and hurting others.
4. I benefit myself and create benefit to others
This is the behavior of the intelligent. This is the goal that everybody as individual and as a group, or as a company or government should try to achieve. It’s not so difficult, just start to share and help others even in small things. Don’t think always and only if the current action will provide us a direct benefit. Maybe it does not provide a direct benefit now, but in the future we will see the fruits of this behavior.
This four points could be better understood in this diagram:
Internet and free and open licenses as Creative Commons and GPL are an example of this. In internet the people usually help others, answering questions, sharing information, as programs, movies, music or any other kind of things, including their time.
Sharing with others, helping others even in small things, even without a direct impact in our bank account or any other direct benefit will help to increase the entropy of welfare.
Benefit our environment will benefit ourselves too.
Finally this is an interesting video about stupidity: